Monday, December 11, 2017

Christmas Music Written by Jews #MusicMovesMe

This seasonal post has become one of my favorite features on my blog.  For the first time, I am sharing it with my friends at Music Moves Me, where our December theme is Christmas music.

But before I do, a belated 101st birthday (December 9) to Issur Danielovitch, better known as actor Kirk Douglas.  Born in upstate New York (and yes, he is Jewish), he has gone on to great acting fame.

But did you know he sometimes sang?  Here, from the movie 20,000. Leagues Under the Sea, is a song called "Whale of a Tale".

Now, since the theme for today is Christmas music and not Kirk Douglas music, onward...

Today, I pose a question: Why do Christians in the United States dream of a White Christmas?  Why is it so important that snow is on the ground?

White Christmas (the song, as sung by Bing Crosby) is the best selling single of all time.

It may surprise you that White Christmas was written by a Jewish song writer.  It may also surprise you that Jews are responsible for many other beloved Christmas songs.

My quest to find out more started in 2010, after reading a NY Times Op Ed.  Many writers have done the research for me:  I thank them, including the wonderful people at Mental Floss and this article. (a must read, based on extensive research).

Some may argue that these are NOT Christmas songs, but rather songs about what I would now call the "secular Christmas". True, these are not hymns.  But it is true that the American celebration of Christmas incorporates many aspects of non-religious symbolism - this ground has been covered by other writers.

I consider them Christmas songs.  I think, in particular, few would argue that "I'll be Home for Christmas" isn't one of the most heartfelt Christmas songs every written.

Additionally, in the several years, I have discovered a wonderful blog and - hey, great minds! - John Holton of The Sound of One Man Typing (a 4M contributor) has also blogged about this very topic. I welcome you to visit John's blog and read even more - a lot more - on this topic.

Here's my list: (this is a You Tube playlist; you can click on the upper left hand corner for all the songs)


1.  White ChristmasIrving Berlin lived to 101, married a Catholic woman back when that type of intermarriage was extremely scandalous (to both families) and wrote a song which defined Christmas for entire generations of American Christians.  (Incidentally, Berlin also wrote "Easter Parade" and "God Bless America".) The next time you wonder if you will be having a white Christmas, and if you can't figure out exactly why that should be so important, well....blame Bing Crosby and Irving Berlin.

2.  Silver Bells:  this one is another movie song, and talks about the bells of the Salvation Army "in the city". (I always assume it is New York City.)
Another Bing Crosby classic.

 3.  Winter Wonderland: the author of this song was a Jewish man from Brooklyn.  The air must have been a lot less polluted in those days.   When I grew up in the New York City of the 1950's, a snowy day was more like a Black Crusted Snow Wasteland.

This version is sung by Johnny Mathis.

4.  The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire). The Nat King Cole version is one of my favorite songs, ever.  This brings back so many memories of the holiday season in the late 60's in midtown Manhattan and the vendors who sold roasted chestnuts.  The fragrance carried for blocks.  For this song, we thank the Jewish songwriters Mel Torme and Robert Wells.

Jack Frost would certainly nip at your nose in NYC.  The climate there is so damp, it feels way colder than it really is.

5.  Let it Snow, Let it Snow, Let it Snow:  the duo, both Jewish, who wrote that song, also wrote "The Christmas Waltz".  This version is sung by Dean Martin.

6.  I'll be Home for Christmas.  Again, sung by Bing Crosby (do you get the feeling I'd rather listen to the older singers?)  As an almost-history major in college, this song makes me think of my aunts and uncles who served during World War II.  This song was originally from the soundtrack of the movie Holiday Inn - yes, the movie that the hotel chain Holiday Inn took its name from.  Two of the three writers of this song were Jewish - Walter Kent and Buck Ram.

Finally, something I picked up in my research:  remember Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer.  It would seem that Johnny Marks, the author of that song (and also "Rockin' Round the Christmas Tree" and "A Holly Jolly Christmas")  was Jewish.

Think of the themes of these songs:  Missing your home.  Childhood nostalgia.  Enjoying a season of lights and happiness. The different child (or reindeer), scorned by others, who becomes the best of all.  These are universal themes, and this is why these songs, I think, are so appealing, no matter who wrote them.

So, thank you for the people responsible for Music Moves Me:and if you love music, why don't you join Xmas Dolly and the other Elves under the mistletoe?

The Head Elf is XmasDolly.  Her co-elves are:  Callie of JAmerican Spice, and ♥Stacy of Stacy Uncorked♥  & The Rockin' elf Cathy from Curious as a Cathy !

Come join us on this musical train to Christmas!

13 comments:

  1. Well, considering that Jesus was Jewish, it all makes sense that Jews would write christmas songs.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alana,

    How very interesting that some of my most beloved Christmas classics were written by Jewish songwriters! I love your creativity behind today's Christmas selections and certainly appreciate the mewsication. One more thing, I did not know Kirk Douglas is still with us and WOW, 101! Happy belated birthday wishes to Kirk! Our own, Stacy Uncorked shares his birthdate but is quite a few years younger. lol Have a joyful Christmas season, my friend and thanks for hitting the dance floor with us today! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. The problem as I see it is Bing Crosby. Given that his voice is emanating from almost every loudspeaker I hear this time of year, i wonder why? As most of these folks want us to avoid Harvey Weinstein films, Roman Polanski works of art, Baltus exhibits...

    ReplyDelete
  4. White Christmas is my all time favorite..and it was my Mothers too! I don't know why we dream of a "White Christmas" though...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very interesting and thanks for the knowledge. I picked White Christmas this week.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I never understood the joy of snow meaning white for Christmas either. It is all the fault of the song's PR! Snow and a white Christmas means to me if you have to travel it is horrible!

    ReplyDelete
  7. So many great songs! All my favourites are here! The Jewish people are SOOO talented! In the arts. The sciences. They are to be envied. And celebrated!

    ReplyDelete
  8. WOW! KIRK DOUGLAS???? BWAHAHAHA TOO FUNNY & ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT! Where on earth did you find that one? bwahahahaha and heck who doesn't like White Christmas!!! That plays and it's officially the Christmas Season! way ta go girlfriend! great post! hugs

    ReplyDelete
  9. I had no idea that so many songs associated with Christmas were written by Jews. Although I do like it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Remember that TV show years ago (I can't remember its name) where all the Jewish people in town decided to give their Christian friends a gift and stand in for them at their places of business so they could have the day off? It's kind of the way I feel about the Christmas songs written by Jewish composers. They aren't about "the Reason for the Season," obviously, but who could imagine Christmas without them?

    Thanks for the shout out!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Then there's this gem - https://youtu.be/BGzO1ghRKp4

    ReplyDelete
  12. What an awesome playlist! And so much educational information - love learning something new every day! :)

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for visiting! Your comments mean a lot to me, and I appreciate each one. These comments are moderated, so they may not post for several hours. If you are spam, you will find your comments in my compost heap, where they will finally serve a good purpose.